Seasonal Header Plugin AreaThe separate seasonal-header plugin will replace this placeholder.

👻 Scrooge Christmas Carol Horror Review: 3 Wonderful Sisters

👻 Scrooge Christmas Carol Horror Review: Dickens Gets a Ghostly Makeover

My Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ 4.9/5

A cold counting house. A miser who hates the season. Chains rattling in the dark. Three sister spirits on the way. And a Christmas Eve that turns into a nightmare.

Welcome to our Scrooge Christmas Carol Horror review.

This Scrooge Christmas Carol Horror review is spoiler free. We all know the story Charles Dickens wrote in 1843. What I will not spoil is how this version tells it, or the surprises it saves for the end.

Discover more Movie Info Here

Scrooge Christmas Carol Horror Review: An Old Tale With New Teeth

The full title of this one is Ebenezer Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror. It comes from The Asylum, the studio behind Sharknado, and it is directed by Marcel Walz.

Let me say this right up front. I loved it.

We have all seen A Christmas Carol more times than we can count. There are musicals, cartoons, Muppets, and serious dramas. So the big question with any new version is simple. What makes this one worth your time?

The answer here is the take. This film leans into the ghost story at the heart of Dickens’ tale and turns up the horror. The three ghosts are wonderful. Dominic Keating as Ebenezer Scrooge pulls you right in. The story is one we know by heart, but it feels fresh again.

This season brought more than one dark version of Scrooge. If you are looking for Ti West’s Ebenezer with Johnny Depp and Ian McKellen, that is a different film. You can read my review of Ebenezer for that one. This review is all about The Asylum’s take.

Ebenezer Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror | Official Trailer

Story Setup: The Tale We All Know

Ebenezer Scrooge is a cruel, cold businessman. He has no patience for Christmas, charity, or kindness. His clerk, Bob Cratchit, works long hours for little pay. His nephew Fred keeps inviting him to Christmas dinner, and Scrooge keeps saying no.

Then, on Christmas Eve, the ghost of his old partner Jacob Marley appears. Marley warns him that spirits are coming. Scrooge must decide whether to heed their warning and change, or stay cold and merciless.

From there, Scrooge is visited by the Ghosts of Christmas Past, Present, and Yet to Come. Each one shows him something he does not want to see.

That is the classic setup, and this film follows it. What changes is the mood. This version plays the hauntings as true horror, with dread and darkness around every corner.

The Cast: A Strong Scrooge and a Haunting Trio

  • Dominic Keating plays Ebenezer Scrooge. Sci fi fans know him as Lieutenant Malcolm Reed on Star Trek: Enterprise.
  • Bryan Barron plays Jacob Marley, the ghost who sets everything in motion. He also appeared in Behold!
  • Llana Barron plays the Ghost of Christmas Past. She is known for Curse of Aurore.
  • Elissa Dowling plays the Ghost of Christmas Present. Horror fans may know her from We Are Still Here and Girl on the Third Floor.
  • Morgan Flanagan plays Belle, the love Scrooge let slip away. She also appears in Master of the Universe.
  • Adam Jones plays Bob Cratchit, Scrooge’s hardworking clerk.
  • Matthew Gademske plays Fred, Scrooge’s cheerful nephew. He also appears in Master of the Universe.
  • Emma Lilian plays Lily.
  • Aubree Liscotti plays Tiny Tim.
  • Jerry Ferrell plays Young Scrooge.
  • Xavier Costello plays Kid.

The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come is not listed in the end credits. I will leave that spirit’s secrets for you to discover.

Dominic Keating: A Scrooge Who Pulls You In

Every Christmas Carol lives or dies with its Scrooge. Dominic Keating delivers.

He plays Scrooge as truly cold and cruel, without turning him into a cartoon. You believe this man could turn away a hungry family without blinking. That makes his journey through the night hit harder.

Keating has the presence to carry the whole film. Scrooge is in nearly every scene, and you never want to look away. He pulled me in from the very start.

Keating was born in Leicester, England, in 1961. His birth name was Dominic Power. Another actor already had that name in the British actors’ union, so he took his mother’s maiden name, Keating.

He is best known for playing Lieutenant Malcolm Reed on Star Trek: Enterprise, which ran for four seasons. He has also appeared in Heroes and played Cain in Robert Zemeckis’ Beowulf. In 2020, his Malcolm Reed even showed up on a set of British postage stamps celebrating Star Trek.

Having a real British actor play Scrooge adds something special. The voice, the manner, and the bite all feel right at home in Dickens’ London.

Dominic Keating as Ebenezer Scrooge in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Review.
Dominic Keating takes on the role of Ebenezer Scrooge in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Review, bringing a darker edge to Dickens’ classic character. © Asylum or related entities. Used for publicity and promotional purposes.

The 3 Sisters: Ghosts You Will Not Forget

Now for my favorite part of the movie. The ghosts.

In this version, the three spirits are women, and they call each other sisters. That simple choice changes the whole feel of the story. Instead of three separate visitors, Scrooge faces a family of spirits working together to save, or condemn, his soul.

Llana Barron plays the Ghost of Christmas Past. She takes Scrooge back to the moments that shaped him, including his lost love, Belle. It is a role that has to balance tenderness with a little menace, and it works.

Elissa Dowling plays the Ghost of Christmas Present. Dowling is a horror veteran with dozens of genre films to her name. She brings that experience here, and her spirit has real presence. She has even worked with director Marcel Walz before, in his film Rootwood.

Then there is the Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come, the most mysterious sister of all. I will not say more than that. Some things are better seen than described.

Together, the three sisters are wonderful. They give this movie its heart and its chills. They are the reason this version stands out from so many others.

Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Review, presenting a terrifying vision of Scrooge's future.
The Ghost of Christmas Yet to Come brings a chilling warning of death and judgment in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Review. © Asylum or related entities. Used for publicity and promotional purposes.

Behind the Scenes: The Asylum and Marcel Walz

The Asylum is one of the most famous independent studios around. It was founded in 1997 by David Michael Latt, David Rimawi, and Sherri Strain, and it is based in Burbank, California.

The studio is known for low budget genre films made quickly and efficiently. Its biggest success came in 2013 with Sharknado, a movie about sharks raining down on Los Angeles. That film went viral and launched a whole franchise. It also led to the zombie series Z Nation.

The Asylum is also known for releasing films with titles similar to big studio movies. The press calls them mockbusters. David Michael Latt prefers to call them tie-ins and says they contain original stories. Ebenezer Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror arrived the same season as Ti West’s Ebenezer, which fits that pattern. But this film stands on its own two feet.

Director Marcel Walz was born in Nuremberg, Germany, in 1986, and now lives in Los Angeles. He started directing while attending film school at just seventeen.

Walz has built a long horror résumé. He directed Blood Feast in 2016, a remake of the Herschell Gordon Lewis classic. He also made Rootwood, Pretty Boy, and Brute 1976, a tribute to 1970s horror.

Joshua Pruett wrote the screenplay. Michael Su served as director of photography, and Monique Paredes was key makeup artist. David Michael Latt and David Rimawi produced, with Paul Bales as co-producer.

The film arrived on digital on October 30, 2026, just in time for Halloween and the start of the holiday season. It runs 85 minutes and is rated TV-14.

Why This Take Works

A Christmas Carol has always been a ghost story. Dickens filled it with chains, graves, and spirits. Many family versions soften those parts. This one does not.

By leaning into horror, the film makes the stakes feel real. Scrooge is not just learning a lesson. He is facing the terror of a wasted life and a lonely death. That makes his journey more powerful.

At the same time, it keeps the heart of the story. The redemption still matters. The message of kindness and second chances still comes through. That balance is hard to pull off, and this film manages it beautifully.

A Southwest Iowa Christmas Tradition

In a lot of Southwest Iowa homes, watching some version of A Christmas Carol is part of the holiday season. Maybe it is an old favorite on TV, a cartoon version with the kids, or a local stage play at church or school.

Whatever version your family watches, the story has a way of bringing people together. It reminds us to slow down, look out for our neighbors, and be grateful for what we have. Those values fit right in here in the Midwest.

This horror take is a fun twist on that tradition. It is not one for the youngest kids, given its TV-14 rating. But for older teens and adults who love a good scare, it would make a great addition to a December movie night.

Llana Barron as the Ghost of Christmas Past in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Review.
Llana Barron portrays the Ghost of Christmas Past in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Review, guiding Ebenezer Scrooge through haunting memories of his earlier life. © Asylum or related entities. Used for publicity and promotional purposes.

A Few Tiny Quibbles

The flaws I found are so minor that I almost left them out. But I tend to notice things like hair, makeup, and costumes, so here they are.

First, the sideburns. The face makeup is fine overall, but the sideburns did not look real to me. Once I noticed them, I kept noticing them.

Second, the characters keep saying “Happy Christmas” instead of “Merry Christmas.” That is common in Britain, so it may simply fit the setting. But Dickens himself used “merry Christmas” throughout the book. Maybe I am just old, but my ears kept catching it.

Third, Tiny Tim is played by a young actress, Aubree Liscotti, and the character is still called a boy. That struck me as an interesting choice, especially with the three ghosts also played by women. Girls playing boys has a long history on stage, so it is not out of place in a Christmas Carol. It just caught my eye.

None of these took away from my enjoyment. They are small notes on an excellent film.

Is Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror Worth Watching?

Absolutely.

Watch it if you love A Christmas Carol and want to see it from a darker angle. Watch it if you enjoy holiday horror with heart. Watch it for Dominic Keating’s Scrooge and the three wonderful sister spirits.

It is also a great pick if you are a fan of The Asylum or Marcel Walz and want to see them take on a classic.

Skip it if you only want a cozy, family friendly version of the story. Skip it if horror is not your thing at Christmas. And keep in mind the TV-14 rating if younger kids are around.

The Kilroy Verdict on Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror

Ebenezer Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror is a wonderful surprise. It takes a story we all know and makes it feel new again.

Dominic Keating gives a commanding performance as Scrooge. The three sister spirits steal the show. Marcel Walz brings a true horror filmmaker’s touch to Dickens’ ghost story without losing its heart.

The only flaws are tiny details, like the sideburns and a few “Happy Christmas” greetings. They are not enough to dim the shine on this one.

Final Thoughts 4.9/5

This one earns a 4.9 out of 5 from Kilroy. Wrapping up this Scrooge Christmas Carol Horror review, I loved it. The three sisters as the ghosts were wonderful, and Dominic Keating as Ebenezer Scrooge pulled me in from start to finish. We all know the plot, but this take was just great. The flaws I found were so minor they barely count.

Ebenezer Scrooge: A Christmas Carol Horror haunts and charms in equal measure, thanks to three wonderful sister spirits. 
ML Lamp, Kilroy Was Here Shop

Bah, humbug? Not this time. This Scrooge earned every bit of Christmas cheer, sideburns and all.

WHO THE HELL IS THIS GUY?

MEET THE MAN BEHIND KILROY
ML Lamp, owner of Kilroy Was Here

ML Lamp

ML Lamp is the old fat bastard behind Kilroy Was Here who apparently doesn't know when to give up. After spending 20 years working in Las Vegas entertainment promotions, he retired in 2002. Most people eventually slow down. Mike opened a collectibles shop.

Then he decided the shop needed to join the modern age, so Kilroy got a website. What started as a place for movies, records and collectibles has turned into this collection of forgotten Americana, horror, old Hollywood, strange history, DIY projects and whatever else catches his attention.

So if you're wondering who writes all this crap, now you know. These are Mike's thoughts, stories and discoveries. Enter at your own risk.