Curtains for Christmas Review: A Holiday Rom Com With a Body Count
My Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ☆ ☆ 3.0/5
A woman who loves Christmas movies.
A man who seems perfect.
A giant talking rat.
And a holiday body count.
Welcome to our Curtains for Christmas Review. This 2024 holiday horror comedy comes from Pittsburgh filmmaker Steve Rudzinski and his company, Silver Spotlight Films.
It takes the cozy made for TV Christmas romance and drags it straight into slasher territory.
This Curtains for Christmas Review is spoiler free. No endings, no twists, and no names on the tombstones.
Curtains for Christmas Review: Cozy Romance Meets Slasher Mayhem
Every December, the cozy Christmas romances take over the TV.
A lonely heart. A perfect stranger. Snow on cue. A kiss before the credits.
Curtains for Christmas asks a wicked little question. What if the biggest fan of those movies decided her own life had to match them?
And what if she would do anything to get there?
Rudzinski calls it a parody of made for TV Christmas romantic comedies. He promised humor, bloodshed, and plenty of Christmas atmosphere.
The answer runs about 68 minutes. It is short, bloody, and silly, with a sweet holiday coating on top.
Story Setup: Holly Wants a Christmas Movie Life
Holly loves Christmas movies.
Not just the famous ones. She knows the obscure titles too, the cheesy ones most people have never heard of.
Her favorite is a sugary little romance called A Cheesy Christmas. She watches it the way some families watch It’s a Wonderful Life every year.
Holly also has a friend named Dominick. Dominick is a talking rat the size of a grown man.
He only exists in Holly’s head. He mocks her taste in movies and eggs her on.
Then Holly meets Jay at the mall. Jay loves Christmas just as much as she does. He is charming, friendly, and full of holiday cheer.
To Holly, it feels like the opening scene of her favorite film.
Real life never follows the script, though. There’s a catch with Jay, and I won’t spoil it.
Let’s just say Holly decides her life deserves to be as perfect as her movies. By any means necessary.
That phrase comes right from the official synopsis. The movie means every word of it.
The Cast: Silver Spotlight Regulars and Indie Horror Faces
- Aleen Isley as Holly. Isley also cowrote and produced the film. She played Jessica in Amityville Christmas Vacation (2022).
- Steve Rudzinski as Jay. Rudzinski also directed, cowrote, and produced. He played Wally Griswold in Amityville Christmas Vacation (2022).
- Michael Varrati as the voice of Dominick. Varrati is also a writer whose credits include the Netflix holiday film Christmas With You.
- Katy Grant as Joan.
- Eric J. Holmes as Howard, Holly’s boyfriend, who is a little short on holiday spirit.
- David Dietz as Bruce. He appeared in Death from Above.
- Andrew Gordon as Clark. He appeared in The Forest Hills (2023).
- Jessa Jupiter Flux (credited as Jessa Flux) as Belle. She played Candy in Murdercise (2023).
- Jess Uhler as Claire.
- Sarah Brunner as Noelle, the heroine of A Cheesy Christmas.
- Michael Barnett as Kris, the leading man of A Cheesy Christmas.
- Rob James as Santa Claus.
- Michael Smyth as Buddy the Assistant.
- Paul Stermer as Cookie Joe.
- John Catheline as the Gingerbread Champion.
- Paul Anderson as Harry the Rat.
- Melissa Sapienza as Marv the Rat.
This is a small indie cast, and many of them are part of the Silver Spotlight family.
Isley and Rudzinski are a regular team. They starred together in Amityville Christmas Vacation before teaming up again here.
Rob James summed up the experience simply. He said it was a blast working with them.
Jessa Jupiter Flux is a familiar face around here. I covered her work in my review of Darbie’s Scream House.
She also turned up as Tammy in Camp Blood Christmas, which I also reviewed. Indie horror fans keep running into her, and that’s a good thing.
Yes, there is a gingerbread competition. And yes, Dominick is not the only rat in town.

Christmas Horror: A Long, Bloody Tradition
Holiday horror is nothing new.
Bob Clark’s Black Christmas (1974) set the tone early. It came out years before Halloween made slashers a box office craze.
Here’s a fun twist. Clark went on to direct A Christmas Story about a decade later. He covered both sides of the holiday.
The early 80s brought a wave of holiday slashers. To All a Goodnight and Christmas Evil both arrived in 1980. Don’t Open Till Christmas followed in 1984.
Christmas Evil put a troubled man in a Santa suit at center stage.
In 1984, Silent Night, Deadly Night stirred up protests outside theaters. It was pulled from some theaters mid run. Today it is a cult classic.
That same year, Gremlins hit theaters. Between the two, Christmas horror was back in a big way.
Silent Night, Deadly Night went on to spawn a string of sequels. I’ve reviewed the whole run here at Kilroy, and it is a wild ride.
Indie filmmakers have kept the tradition alive ever since. Every December brings new ones, from big releases to tiny homegrown productions.
Notice a pattern? Most of the classic Christmas killers are men, and a lot of them wear a red suit.
Curtains for Christmas flips that. Rudzinski has described it as a parody with a female killer as the lead.
Holly doesn’t need a Santa suit. She has a favorite movie and a rat whispering in her ear.
Behind the Scenes: A Christmas Fan Makes a Christmas Slasher
Steve Rudzinski loves Christmas. He loves horror just as much.
Rudzinski was born in Leesburg, Florida, in 1987. He has said he knew he wanted to be a director after seeing Army of Darkness at age 12.
He has kept a steady pace ever since. Since 2011, he has directed about one film a year.
Curtains for Christmas is his sixteenth project and thirteenth feature with Silver Spotlight Films.
Early titles include Everyone Must Die! (2012) and Slaughter Drive (2017).
He is best known for the CarousHELL trilogy, a cult favorite among indie horror fans.
Then there are the Meowy films, holiday comedies with talking animals. A Meowy Halloween arrived in 2018, followed by A Meowy Christmas Vacation in 2020.
Shingles: The Movie, a horror comedy anthology, came out in 2023.
His holiday horror comedy Amityville Christmas Vacation won him a Fangoria Chainsaw Award in 2023. He was also named Best Filmmaker in Pittsburgh in 2023 and 2024.
The idea for this one started at home. Aleen Isley came up with it while watching Christmas rom coms with Rudzinski.
Isley has said she thinks horror and comedy complement each other well.
Varrati brings his own writing background to the project. His credits include The Boulet Brothers’ Dragula.
Michael Varrati had kind words for his director. He said Rudzinski is the kind of filmmaker who makes the genre space special.
Mike Trebilcock composed the score. Effects work is credited to Cody Ruch.

Made in Pittsburgh: Micro Budget, Big Holiday Heart
Rudzinski is a Pittsburgh filmmaker through and through.
He calls his work niche films on a micro budget. No big studio money. No famous stars.
That hasn’t kept his films at home. Silver Spotlight films have screened theatrically around the world. Rudzinski has said his work has taken him to Barcelona, Prague, Brazil, and Tokyo.
Rats are a bit of a Silver Spotlight tradition too. The 2020 film A Meowy Christmas Vacation featured two talking animals, a cat and a rat.
Dominick carries that torch.
Rudzinski is a regular on the horror convention circuit too. His favorite is HorrorHound Weekend in Cincinnati, which he calls the San Diego Comic-Con of horror.
That’s a Midwest show, and it’s good to see a Midwest convention get that kind of love.
The Gay Angle: Two Couples Under the Mistletoe
Rudzinski identifies as bisexual and has cast many LGBTQ actors in his films.
He has pointed to positive LGBTQ representation in Curtains for Christmas through two featured couples.
Bruce and Clark, played by David Dietz and Andrew Gordon, are the gay male couple.
Belle and Claire, played by Jessa Jupiter Flux and Jess Uhler, are the lesbian couple.
I won’t explain how they fit into Holly’s plans. That’s a big part of the fun in the middle of the movie.
Plenty of cozy holiday romances still play it safe. This one doesn’t.

A Movie Inside the Movie: A Cheesy Christmas
Holly’s favorite film gets real screen time.
Sarah Brunner plays Noelle and Michael Barnett plays Kris in the A Cheesy Christmas scenes.
Brunner has said the part let her live out a dream of appearing in a holiday TV style romance.
Barnett joked that his rat costar kept leaving the set until someone handed over Ruffles.
Isley and Rudzinski talked about turning that movie within the movie into a full feature. They pictured it as a straight rom com, with no horror at all.
Here’s the fun part for collectors. A Cheesy Christmas now has its own IMDb listing for 2024, with Rudzinski credited as writer and in the role of Bernie.
A fake movie became a real one.
A Disc Release for Collectors
This is the part that gets the collector in me excited.
Curtains for Christmas came out on disc on July 10, 2024. A true Christmas in July release.
The disc includes an audio commentary, interviews, bloopers, and more. Copies are sold through the Silver Spotlight Films online store.
For indie horror, a physical copy is always worth grabbing. Small runs have a way of disappearing.
Commentary tracks and bloopers matter on a film like this. They show how a tiny crew pulls off a holiday slasher, and that’s half the fun for collectors.
If you shop the holiday horror shelf, this one belongs next to your other cult Christmas titles.

Where It Stumbles
Let me be upfront.
The one fight scene looks lame. It never sells the danger.
There are also some slow drags. Even at 68 minutes, a few stretches sit still too long.
Those two things hold the movie back. They are the reason this one lands at three stars.
What Works
Now the good stuff, and there is plenty of it.
I really like the story. It’s a simple idea with a sharp hook.
Dominick the rat is fresh. I have never seen a holiday slasher with a rodent sidekick living in the killer’s head.
The script has some fun lines. Dominick gets plenty of them, and Holly gets her share too.
I really liked the set decorations. For an independent movie, somebody spent real time dressing these rooms for the season.
The establishing shots surprised me too. Those quick outside views tell you where you are before a scene starts.
Small indie crews often skip them to save time. This crew took the time, and it makes the film feel like a real holiday TV movie.
Then there are the kills. They feel like the old 80s horror movies that filled the video store shelves.
Blood, a good setup, and a creative way to end a scene. That’s the 80s formula, and this film follows it.
Is Curtains for Christmas Worth Watching?
If you like your holiday movies with a little blood on the candy cane, yes.
Here’s who will get the most out of it:
- Holiday horror fans who love the old 80s slashers
- Folks who know every cozy Christmas romance by heart
- Indie horror fans who enjoy scrappy, homegrown filmmaking
- Collectors hunting for oddball Christmas titles
- Viewers looking for LGBTQ representation in holiday horror
It’s also a good pick for long, cold winter nights here in Southwest Iowa. It’s short enough to watch after supper and still get to bed on time.
If you need big budget polish, skip it. If you love indie horror with heart, give it a spin.
The Kilroy Verdict on Curtains for Christmas
Curtains for Christmas is a holiday rom com parody with real slasher teeth.
The story works. The rat is fresh. The lines are fun.
The set decorations and establishing shots show a level of care you don’t always see in micro budget films.
The kills bring back that old 80s feel.
The fight scene falls flat, and a few slow stretches drag the pace down.
Even so, this one has earned a spot on the Christmas horror shelf.
Final Thoughts 3/5
This one earns a 3 out of 5 from Kilroy. Wrapping up this Curtains for Christmas Review, the story is fun and the rat is fresh. The sets show real care, and the kills feel like old 80s horror. A lame fight scene and some slow drags keep it from climbing higher.
“Curtains for Christmas carves a bloody, fresh path through holiday romance clichés.”
ML Lamp, Kilroy Was Here Shop
Pour the cocoa, hang the stockings, and check the attic for rats before you press play.






