🕵️ Before Dallas Review: Every Rumor You Grew Up Hearing, in One Movie
My Rating: ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ ⭐ 4.5/5
A president with secrets. A crooner with connections. A Chicago boss who expects his favors repaid. A blonde star who knows too much. And a city waiting one year before Dallas.
Welcome to our Before Dallas review.
This Before Dallas review is spoiler free. I will cover the setup, the cast, the craft behind the camera, and the one flaw I could not get past. How the film plays out its biggest moments stays in the vault.
Before Dallas Review: A Breath of Fresh Air
Every American over a certain age grew up hearing the stories. The Kennedys and the Mob. Sinatra in the middle. Marilyn and the president. Chicago votes in 1960. Whispers, rumors, and theories passed around kitchen tables for decades.
Before Dallas takes all of those stories and packs them into one movie. It is a docudrama, which means it dramatizes history and the theories that surround it. It does not ask you to believe every word. It asks you to imagine what might have happened behind closed doors.
And it works. This is one of the most entertaining indie films I have watched in a long time. The lighting is strong. The editing is sharp. The script ties a tangled web of people and events into a story that is easy to follow and hard to stop watching.
It has one glaring flaw, and I will get to it. But overall, this movie was a breath of fresh air.
Story Setup: Favors, Betrayal, and a Plot in Chicago
The story opens in America in 1960. John F. Kennedy is running for president, and the race is close. According to the story the film tells, the Kennedys use their friend Frank Sinatra as a go between. Through Sinatra, they ask Chicago Mob boss Sam Giancana for a favor.
The favor is simple, at least on paper. Giancana helps swing union votes toward Kennedy. In return, he expects future protection from government prosecution. It is a handshake deal between powerful men who all think they are in control.
Then the deal sours. Once in office, JFK appoints his brother Bobby as Attorney General. Bobby declares war on organized crime. To Giancana, that looks like betrayal. Favors turn into grudges, and grudges turn into danger.
Woven through all of it is Marilyn Monroe. The film portrays her as JFK’s mistress, caught between the most powerful people in the country. Her mysterious death in Los Angeles becomes a turning point in the story.
From there, the film builds toward an elaborate plan to assassinate President Kennedy in Chicago in the fall of 1962. That is one year before Dallas, which gives the movie its title. Everyone knows what happened on November 22, 1963. This film asks a chilling question. What if the crosshairs were set a year earlier?
That is all I will reveal. The fun is in watching how the pieces fit together.
The Cast: Famous Faces From History
Playing real people is one of the hardest jobs in acting. Audiences already have a picture in their heads. Every voice, walk, and smile gets compared to the real thing.
- Aaron Clum plays John F. Kennedy, the charming young president at the center of the storm.
- Sara Copeland plays Marilyn Monroe, the screen icon caught in a web of powerful men.
- Pete Berwick plays Frank Sinatra, the friend who becomes the go between.
- Frank Calabrese plays Sam Giancana, the Chicago Mob boss who wants his favor repaid.
- Niko Caponigro plays Bobby Kennedy, the Attorney General who turns up the heat on the Mob.
Giancana is the engine of this story. He is the man who feels used, and his anger drives the plot forward. The tension between him and the Kennedy brothers gives the movie its backbone.
Sinatra is an interesting piece of the puzzle too. He is a friend to both sides, which puts him in a dangerous spot. The film uses him as the bridge between Washington and Chicago.
Bobby Kennedy plays a key role as the brother who will not look the other way. His crusade against organized crime is what sets the whole chain of events in motion.
And then there is Marilyn. She is the most famous face in the film and the most tragic figure. Sara Copeland had the toughest job in the cast, stepping into the shoes of one of the most recognizable women who ever lived. Unfortunately, the costume department did her no favors. More on that later.

Behind the Scenes: An Author Brings His Own Novel to Life
Before Dallas is based on the novel Princes and Thieves, written by Vito Brancato. Brancato did not hand his book off to someone else. He adapted it himself.
He also wrote the screenplay, directed the film, and edited it. That means the story, the pacing, and the final cut all came from the same person. When I say the script and editing are strong, the credit goes straight to him.
Brancato’s background is one of the most colorful I have come across. He got his start in professional wrestling on Chicago Championship Wrestling, which aired on SportsChannel. He worked behind the camera as an editor, writer, director, and producer. He also worked in front of it as a villain named Tony “The Razor” DiVito for four years.
He later turned that ring persona into The Razor Show, a half hour comedy that built a cult following in Chicago. From there, he moved into filmmaking.
Here is a detail that shows how long this story has been on his mind. Brancato previously made a dramatic film for PBS called Blackstone: The Chicago Plot to Kill JFK. Before Dallas expands that idea into a full feature, built on his own novel.
Brancato also won awards for a short film called Driving John Lennon. It imagines a late night drive and private talk between Elvis Presley and John Lennon. That film won a Silver Remi at WorldFest Houston. Clearly, he has a gift for imagining what famous people said when nobody else was listening.
And here is my favorite bit of trivia. Brancato runs an old world Italian coffee shop called Avito Caffe on Chicago’s west side. It sits in a building once owned by Al Capone. The cafe doubles as his production office and as a film set for his projects. You cannot make this stuff up.
The Craft: Lighting, Editing, and Script
For an independent film, Before Dallas looks and feels polished in the areas that matter most.
The lighting sets the mood and gives the film a polished look that many indie movies never reach. It helps sell the feeling that you are watching secrets unfold behind closed doors. Andre Shane served as director of photography.
The editing keeps the story moving. A film like this could easily get lost in names, dates, and side plots. Instead, the pacing stays tight. Each scene pushes the story forward and builds tension toward Chicago.
The script deserves big credit too. It takes decades of rumors and theories and turns them into a clear, gripping story. You never feel lost, even with so many famous players on the board. That is a hard trick to pull off.
The musical score by Vito Greco adds to the mood without overpowering the drama.
The film runs one hour and 41 minutes and is rated for mature audiences. You can stream it on Prime Video.
The Chicago Connection: A Midwest Story
Most JFK movies focus on Dallas. This one shifts the spotlight to Chicago, and that makes it feel close to home for Midwest viewers.
Chicago has always loomed large in the Kennedy story. The 1960 election results from Chicago have been argued about for more than six decades. Sam Giancana was the most powerful Mob figure in the city. Placing an assassination plot in the heart of Chicago gives this story a Midwest heartbeat.
Brancato himself is a Chicago filmmaker, and that shows. The film understands the city’s history and its legends.
Here in Southwest Iowa, Chicago has always felt like the big city on the horizon. Plenty of us grew up hearing about the Outfit, the Kennedys, and what really happened in 1960. Those stories traveled across the Midwest by word of mouth. Watching them come to life on screen felt like hearing those old kitchen table conversations all over again.
Fact, Rumor, and Docudrama
It is important to know what kind of movie this is. Before Dallas is a docudrama. It takes real people and real events and blends them with theories, rumors, and dramatized conversations.
Some of the story is solid history. Robert Kennedy really did serve as Attorney General and pursued organized crime. Marilyn Monroe really did die in Los Angeles in August 1962. Sam Giancana really was the boss of the Chicago Mob.
Other parts are the stuff of debate. Claims about the Mob swinging votes, the details of Marilyn’s relationships, and plots against the president have been argued over for decades. The film presents its version of events with confidence. Viewers should enjoy it as a gripping what if, not as a history lesson.
That is exactly what makes it fun. If you grew up hearing these stories, the movie feels like someone finally connected all the dots on one big board.

Where It Stumbles
Now for the flaw. And it is a big one.
The costuming is the weakest part of the film. Many of the outfits look like they came from a thrift shop rather than the early 1960s. For a movie built on recreating a famous era, that breaks the spell more often than it should.
The worst offender is Marilyn Monroe’s wig. It is so unconvincing that every time Marilyn appears on screen, it pulls you right out of the story. Marilyn’s look is one of the most famous images in American history. When it misses this badly, there is no hiding it. My reaction every single time was the same. OMG.
That is a shame, because it is not fair to the actress. She is stuck carrying a costume choice that undercuts her every scene. With a better wig, her scenes would have landed with much more impact.
I understand that indie films work on tight budgets. Period costumes and quality wigs are expensive. But when the rest of the film is this well crafted, the costuming stands out even more.
Outside of that, my complaints are minor. The film is strong where it counts most: story, lighting, and editing.
Is Before Dallas Worth Watching?
Absolutely.
Watch it if you grew up hearing JFK rumors and always wondered how they all fit together. Watch it if you love political thrillers, Mob stories, or 1960s history. Watch it if you appreciate independent filmmaking that punches above its weight.
It is especially worth watching if you are from the Midwest. The Chicago angle gives it a fresh take on a story most people only connect with Dallas.
Skip it if you only want strict, documented history. This is a docudrama, and it leans into theory and speculation. Also, be ready for that wig. You have been warned.
The Kilroy Verdict on Before Dallas
Before Dallas is a riveting, well crafted docudrama that takes every JFK rumor and conspiracy you have ever heard and turns them into one compelling story.
Vito Brancato deserves real credit. He wrote the novel, adapted it, directed it, and edited it. His love for this story shines through in every scene.
The lighting is moody and effective. The editing is tight. The script turns a tangled web of history into a story you can follow and enjoy.
Only the costuming holds it back, especially that shocking Marilyn wig. Fix that, and this movie would be close to perfect.
Final Thoughts 4.5/5
This one earns a 4.5 out of 5 from Kilroy. Wrapping up this Before Dallas review, this movie was a breath of fresh air. It took every conspiracy and rumor I heard growing up and packed it into one gripping film. The lighting, editing, and script are all very good. The only flaw is the costuming. Still, the story is strong enough to carry you right past it.
Before Dallas weaves decades of JFK rumors into a riveting, smartly made thriller.
ML Lamp, Kilroy Was Here Shop
Some secrets stayed buried for decades. That wig should have stayed buried with them.






