Tammy Grimes Broadway Star
Tammy Grimes a true Broadway Star
🎭 Tammy Grimes (1934–2016) was a Tony-winning actress, singer, and stage icon known for her distinctive voice, sharp wit, and unforgettable presence on Broadway. Often described as a performer who existed just slightly outside the mainstream, Grimes made her name in theater but left her mark in television, music, and film. While not a household name today, she was once considered Broadway royalty and a true original in the entertainment world.
Born Tammy Lee Grimes on January 30, 1934, in Lynn, Massachusetts, she studied drama at Stephens College and later at Neighborhood Playhouse in New York City, where she trained under the legendary Sanford Meisner. From the start, it was clear she had something different—an eccentric blend of charm, theatricality, and poise that made her magnetic on stage.
Tammy Grimes' big break came in 1960 when she originated the title role in “The Unsinkable Molly Brown” on Broadway. Her performance earned her the Tony Award for Best Featured Actress in a Musical in 1961, beating out rising stars like Barbra Streisand and solidifying her as a force on the theatrical stage. That role, filled with energy, comedy, and grit, would forever define her career, even as she stepped into other mediums in the decades that followed.
Early Life
Tammy Grimes was born into a conservative New England family in Lynn, Massachusetts, the daughter of Eola and Luther Nichols Grimes. Her father was a banker, but Tammy was drawn early to performance, often reciting poetry and mimicking radio personalities as a child. Her dramatic flair stood out even in school plays, where her teachers encouraged her to pursue the stage.
After attending Stephens College in Missouri—a school known for its strong performing arts program—Grimes moved to New York City to study acting at the prestigious Neighborhood Playhouse, where she trained with Sanford Meisner, one of the most influential acting coaches of the 20th century. She absorbed his emphasis on spontaneity and emotional truth, skills that would serve her well in live theater and later, in television. By her early twenties, she was already appearing in off-Broadway productions, slowly building a reputation for being eccentric, elegant, and impossible to ignore.
Stage and Screen Career
Tammy Grimes’ defining role came with the original Broadway production of “The Unsinkable Molly Brown” in 1960, where she starred as the bold, larger-than-life Titanic survivor. Directed by Dore Schary, the show became a major hit and earned her the Tony Award in 1961. Her quirky charm and unconventional delivery helped her beat out rising stars like Barbra Streisand, who would explode onto the scene just a few years later.
Tammy Grimes followed that success with appearances in Noël Coward’s “High Spirits” (1964), a musical adaptation of Blithe Spirit, which earned her another Tony nomination. Coward was so fond of Grimes that he once declared she was “a lovely, talented creature who’s just the right degree of mad.” She also headlined productions of “Private Lives”, “The Merry Widow”, and “The Only Game in Town,” frequently playing women who were headstrong, eccentric, or delightfully off-kilter.
In 1966, Grimes starred in her own short-lived TV sitcom, “The Tammy Grimes Show,” produced by William Dozier (of Batman fame). Though it was canceled after just four episodes, her television presence continued through guest spots on shows like “Murder, She Wrote,” “Love Boat,” “Playhouse 90,” and even the animated “ABC Weekend Special.” Her stage-trained voice made her a natural for voiceovers and narrations, and she recorded several spoken-word albums and children’s audiobooks in the 1980s and ’90s.
Despite being the original choice for the role of Samantha Stephens in Bewitched, Grimes famously turned it down. The role instead went to Elizabeth Montgomery, who became a television icon. Grimes, for her part, had no regrets—she preferred the stage, calling television "too flat" for her theatrical instincts. While she never found long-term success in Hollywood, she remained a favorite among casting directors for her unmistakable delivery and presence.
Explore the Biographies of Iconic Music Stars
Vinyl Record Highlights
Tammy Grimes Sings I'm Always Chasing Rainbows
Though best known for her stage work, Tammy Grimes left behind a small but collectible discography that’s become a treasure trove for vinyl enthusiasts. Her original cast recording of “The Unsinkable Molly Brown” (1960, Capitol Records) remains the most sought-after LP among collectors. With Grimes in full theatrical form, the album showcases her unique voice and comedic timing. Pristine copies with the original jacket can fetch $40 to $100, especially if sealed or autographed.
Another key collectible is the cast recording of “High Spirits” (1964, ABC-Paramount), where Grimes starred opposite Edward Woodward and Beatrice Lillie. Featuring music and lyrics by Noël Coward, the album captures her in one of her most celebrated roles. Limited pressings and Broadway nostalgia drive prices up, often $30–$75 depending on condition.
Grimes also released a self-titled solo album, “Tammy Grimes” (
Tammy Grimes Vinyl Album For Sale on Amazon. Click Photo to Buy
), which blended theatrical songs with cabaret stylings. It's a lesser-known gem with her signature dramatic flair and spoken-sung delivery. Due to its lower production run, it's harder to find and can command $50 or more among Broadway and vintage vocal collectors.
Collectors should also look out for oddities, like spoken-word children's albums and compilation records featuring her narration or musical appearances. These often show up in bargain bins, but rarer ones—especially with original artwork—can quietly climb in value as Broadway vinyl continues its revival among niche fans.
Personal Life
Tammy Grimes’ personal life was as colorful as her stage career. She was briefly married to actor Christopher Plummer—their union lasted from 1956 to 1960 and produced one child, Amanda Plummer, who would go on to become an acclaimed actress in her own right (The Fisher King, Pulp Fiction, Hunger Games). Despite the short-lived marriage, Grimes and Plummer reportedly maintained mutual respect for each other’s work throughout their lives.
Known for her eccentric style and bohemian charm, Tammy Grimes was a fixture in New York’s theatrical and literary circles. She often described herself as “a character actress in leading-lady roles” and was rarely seen without a flowing scarf, a dramatic coat, or her unmistakably theatrical mannerisms. Friends and colleagues often compared her to Tallulah Bankhead and Katharine Hepburn, both in voice and personality.
Grimes was also deeply private offstage. She rarely courted press, kept her social life guarded, and preferred the company of fellow performers, writers, and directors. In her later years, she taught acting, did occasional voiceover work, and appeared at retrospectives honoring classic Broadway productions. Though never mainstream-famous, she was deeply respected by those who understood the art of stagecraft.
Legacy
Tammy Grimes may never have become a mainstream icon, but within the theater world, her name still carries weight. She was a performer’s performer—bold, theatrical, and wholly original. Her 1961 Tony win for The Unsinkable Molly Brown secured her place in Broadway history, and her distinctive voice and offbeat charm continue to influence stage actors who dare to bring something unusual to their roles.
Though her television and film appearances were limited, her work left a lasting impression, especially in niche roles and voiceover performances. Her daughter, Amanda Plummer, has carried the torch in her own offbeat way, with many critics noting the inherited eccentricity and depth both women brought to their characters. Through Amanda and through her timeless cast recordings, Tammy’s theatrical flame still flickers.
Today, collectors, Broadway star historians, and vintage vinyl fans keep her name alive. She may not have sought the spotlight in the traditional sense, but Tammy Grimes carved out a space for herself on her own terms—flamboyant, intelligent, and fiercely unforgettable.
ML Lamp is the owner of Kilroy Was Here. After his 20 years of working in Las Vegas in the entertainment promotions field, Mr. Lamp retired in 2002 from his job to pursue his passion for collectibles. Now as a guest speaker and author he’s living the dream, and sharing his warmth with You.